Threat Level: green Handler on Duty: Johannes Ullrich

SANS ISC: Thunderbolt Security Speculations - Internet Security | DShield SANS ISC InfoSec Forums


Sign Up for Free!   Forgot Password?
Log In or Sign Up for Free!
Thunderbolt Security Speculations

Today, Apple release a new set of Macbook Pros, sporting the first implementation of "Thunderbolt", a new interconnect technology based on what Intel so far called "Lightpeek". It promisses 10 GBit/sec duplex connectivity to everything from storage to video devices. The technology is similar to Firewire (aka i.Link, IEEE 1394) in some ways. Like for Firewire, multiple devices may be daisy chained. However, if a display port display is used as part of the chain, the display has to be the last device in the chain.

One speculation put forward in an article in the register [1] is that devices connected via Thunderbolt are not authenticated and like for firewire, have full bus access. This speculation is supported by the so far available material form Intel and Apple. Like with Firewire, this bus would provide direct access to RAM and possibly disks. As a result, a malicious device may be able to read RAM and disks without authentication.

These attacks have been shown to work for Firewire, and have been used for example in memory forensics to extract memory content from live systems. However, with the larger variety of devices expected for thunderbolt, it may be more of a threat. In particular, the scenario put forward in the article: Connecting a laptop to a projector at a conference via display port. There is no telling if inside the projector a second device sits in line waiting to extract memory from the attached laptop.

As mentioned in the title: At this point, I don't think anybody has had a chance to experiment with this yet, and I am not aware of any display link projectors. Actually almost all of the time at conferences I find good old VGA (not DVI or HDMI). But this may of course change in the future.

[1] http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/02/24/thunderbolt_mac_threat/

------
Johannes B. Ullrich, Ph.D.
SANS Technology Institute
Twitter

I will be teaching next: Defending Web Applications Security Essentials - SANS Munich July 2019

Johannes

3535 Posts
ISC Handler
I'm sure Apple will abandon it after a while...much like they did with Firewire.
James

34 Posts
For now, this is pure speculation. Nobody has yet been able to test. This article (in the register) is a perfect example of FUD!
James
1 Posts
I think the title of the post identifies that it is speculation... worthwhile and most likely accurate speculation! I would hestitate buying a fleet of Thunderbolt enabled machines for enterprise users if I were aware that they might have the same security issues as firewire.
jtwaldo

17 Posts

Sign Up for Free or Log In to start participating in the conversation!